Galatians 4:12-20    Gospel Church vs. Legal Church     March 26, 2006

 

SI:   Paul continues his strong appeal to Galatians not to reject the Gospel.

 

INTRO:  I know you’ve heard one about man marooned on desert island 10 years.

   When he was rescued, rescuers saw that he had built three buildings.

What are these buildings?

   This is my house—Many a night it’s sheltered me from elements.

What about this building? 

   This is my church—Many a Sabbath I’ve met the Lord there.

What’s that building?

   That’s the church I used to go to.

 

The old saying is that if you ever find the perfect church—

   don’t join it, because when you do it will no longer be perfect.

 

When you read the New Testament letters that Paul and the other apostles

   wrote to the early churches, realize very quickly that there were no perfect

   churches back then either—All of them had problems.

 

Case could be made that the church with the most problems was church in Corinth.

   Few years ago someone wrote a commentary on 1 and 2 Corinthians.

   “Twenty Controversies That Almost Killed A Church”

 

Compared to the Corinthian church, the Galatian church just had one problem.

   But it was such a bad problem that Paul uses the strongest language

   found in any of his letters. 

 

In one word, the problem with the Galatian churches was legalism.

   Paul calls it the works of the law.

Legalism is making some religious ritual or moral behavior

   one of the things necessary in the formula for getting God’s approval.

 

The tricky thing about legalism is that when it appears in a church or Christian,

   it never denies that Jesus is the Savior, or that he died on cross for sins,

   or that you have to put your faith in him.

It affirms all of those things.  But it also says or implies—

   that real Christians, true Christians,

   those who really have the stamp of God’s approval do certain things.

So a person or a church can become legalistic and all the while

   they are thinking they are just becoming more serious Christians—

   when in fact they are turning their backs on the Gospel and on Jesus.

 

The Gospel is that you are a terrible sinner but you are approved and loved by God

   through faith in Jesus Christ alone—not by religion or morality. 

When you introduce a religious or moral requirement to get right with God—

   then you reduce Jesus Christ to one cog in your program of self-salvation. 

 

That’s what was happening in the Galatian churches.

   Their particular form of legalism was keeping certain Old Testament rituals—

   circumcision, holy days in Jewish calendar, food laws.

These things not wrong in themselves—when implied or stated that these

   are what make a real Christian—then you have legalism. 

 

So far we have seen Paul use a number of different arguments to show

   Galatians their legalism and argue against it.

His personal experience—conversion, conflict with Peter.

Doctrine of justification—logic that destroys legalism.

Biblical example of the faith and salvation of Abraham.

Analogy of slavery verses sonship—what that means for Christian life.

 

Now, in this passage he makes a very personal appeal and argument—

   he reminisces about the early days of the Galatian church.

Remember what it was like when I first came to you, first heard Gospel?

   Remember what our church was like back then?  Remember how sweet it was?

Now look at what it is becoming under this legalism.

   Contrasts the spirit and attitudes of the church under Gospel, under legalism.

 

As we study this passage, I want to draw out five of these contrasts—

   between Gospel church and a legal church.

   As we do, want us to look at ourselves—body and individuals. 

One thing I’ve learned in study of Galatians—easy to find examples in other

   churches, in other Christians—very hard to find in self, your church.

Nature of legalism. 

   Not denial of faith in Christ—masquerades as getting more serious spiritually.

 

Note takers:  Two columns:  Gospel Church vs. Legal Church.

 

1.  A Gospel church is flexible, a legal church is rigid.

Paul starts by reminding them that it was a physical illness of some kind

   that caused him to preach the Gospel to them for the first time.

vs. 13  As you know, it was because of an illness that I first preached the Gospel to you.”

 

Most scholars today think it was a disease of Paul’s eyes.

   “You would have torn out your eyes and given them to me.”

Could be a figure of speech:  I’d give you the shirt off my back.

   But hints that Paul did have some kind of eye disease that permanently

   harmed his vision.  End of Galatians: 

   “See what large letters I use as I write to you with my own hand.”

Incident in Acts where he does not recognize high priest—bad eyesight?

   Could this be the thorn in the flesh Paul prayed God would take away?

 

But this is the point—He was in Galatia either because of a detour from his

   planned itinerary or because of a delay in his planned schedule.

Either way, he was not planning to preach to these people—

   but his illness caused it to happen that way.

 

This shows us that ministry does not happen strictly according to human plan.

   Paul had not targeted Galatia in his strategic planning sessions—

   but God brought him there through an illness.

Certainly doesn’t mean that planning is wrong.  Paul continued to plan.

   Consistently targeted large cities in his church planting.

 

But it does show us that God providentially orders events in the life of church

   and these can go against the plans and programs we have in place. 

The Gospel gives a church the grace to be flexible. 

   Enables a church body to be willing to let God edit plans and programs.

   Our standing before God does not depend on things working according to plan.

 

Legalism makes a church rigid and resistant to God’s providence.

   Disruption of plans and programs cause despair or anger.

   An inability to see that God is at work.

  

Allison and I pray for our Covenant Group on Wednesdays at lunch.

   Pray that our lives bound together in Christian love. 

And, of course I always pray that we will have a good attendance.

 

Few years ago, one of those Wednesday nights where one after another cancelled.

   Turned out only one couple would be coming.

I was in legalistic gloom.  Our Covenant Group is shot.

   It’s not going according to the plan.  What a lousy Covenant Group.

  What will Steve Nyquist say?

 

Guess what?  It was wonderful. 

   Lord opened our hearts to each other in a way that could not have happened

   if even one other person had been there. 

God in his providence bends the plans and programs of the church.

   The Gospel gives a church gracious flexibility.

   Often times things we plan reach people we don’t expect—

   in ways we don’t expect.

That takes away all glory from us and gives it to the Lord.


2.  A Gospel church is welcoming, a legal church is alienating.

This contrast is very clear.

 

vs. 14  You welcomed me as if I were an angel of God, as if I were Christ Jesus himself. 

vs. 17  What they want is to alienate you from us so that you may be zealous for them.”

 

In those early days of the Galatian church, when the pure Gospel

   was so much on everyone’s mind, it made the church a welcoming body.

Paul reminds them of how welcoming they were.

   My illness was a trial, you didn’t treat me with contempt or scorn.

 

Some commentators say in the Galatian culture,

   blindness was considered a judgment from the gods—cultural bias against

   person with an eye disease—like AIDS

Others commentators say that Paul’s illness, whatever it was—

   was particularly disgusting.  He was unpleasant to look at.  Eyes infected.

   “Even though my sickness was revolting to you . . .”

 

Whether it was a cultural bias against people with eye problems

   or simply physical revulsion at a man’s disease—this is the point.

The Gospel enabled this young church of young believers

   to welcome Paul as if he were and angel or Jesus Christ himself. 

 

When a church has the pure Gospel, free from legalism—

   then you have a group of people who all know that they did nothing

   to earn God’s favor and approval.  It was all God’s grace in Christ.

That provides amazing power to welcome everyone as if welcoming Christ himself. 

 

I will never forget a comment a friend of ours made when lived in Florida.

   She and her husband did not attend our church,

   another church of different denomination, very different—raise eyebrows. 

Telling us about woman in their church,

   come off the streets from life of prostitution and drug use—embraced, converted.

   Friend said:  Not the kind of person you have in your church.

 

She didn’t say that to judge us,

   more an observation about the social make-up of community.

Our church was in a well-to-do retirement community—

   theirs in blue-collar, ethnic part of city.  But it stung a little bit. 

Wondered what would we do with a person like that?

   Would we have welcomed her as if we were welcoming Christ or angel?

Notice Paul’s analysis of why these legalists end up alienating—

   so that you may be zealous for them. 

Interested in people who can advance their program and agenda for church.

   Because legalism—whether operating in an individual or in a church

   is about a program of self-salvation.

A way of proving acceptability before God.

 

It is impossible to welcome people as if they were Christ himself

   with a legalistic spirit—because they aren’t going to fit in.

Even when do welcome people—it’s because of external things—

   not because of the grace of Christ poured out on us.

 

Gospel gives church the ability to be a welcoming body. 


3.  A Gospel church is maturing, a legal church is regressing.

What was the goal of the legalists?  What did they want for this church?

vs. 17  that you may be zealous for them”

   The wanted a church full of fans who were emotionally dependent on them.

 

Why?  Legalism is all about what we accomplish and give to God to get approval.

   Legalistic church leaders, legalistic ministers do not do the work of ministry

   because they are sure of their salvation—do it to get security of salvation.

The way that most often expresses itself is the need to have members need them.

   They need disciples who are wrapped up in them—obeying them, adoring them.

   This assures them that they are great believers, approved by God.

 

What does that mean for practical ministry?

they are zealous to win you over”

   This is a way of saying:  “They are telling you what you want to hear.”

   They are tickling your ears.  They are pandering to get loyalty.

This can be done in many different ways. 

   Could be by being afraid to say anything firm.

 

Could even be very harsh.  Some legalistic ministers are tyrants.

   Attract people who love to have preachers who make them feel bad.

Think haven’t gone to church if don’t come away feeling bad—

   because if feel bad, must mean really paying for sins, getting right with God.

 

But what is the result of this co-dependent loop of legalism?

   In the end, what you have is spiritual regression.

 

What was Paul’s goal for this young church?  The exact opposite.

   vs. 19  My dear children, for whom I am again in the pains of childbirth

   until Christ is formed in you.”

 

Paul wanted this church to be maturing.

   What an expressive way of describing spiritual maturity:  Christ formed in you.

   As if entire inner life—thoughts, wishes, dreams—like Christ’s.

   Then that will come out in your words and deeds.

 

You might say, wait a minute.  Paul says in vs. 12 “Become like me.”

   But Paul is only being an example to the Galatians in order for them to be

   changed into the likeness of Christ.

He’s not trying to get fans, he’s trying to get this church to follow Christ as he does.

   Paul doesn’t want the Galatians to get dependent on him but on Christ.

 

One minister put it this way:  Paul doesn’t say “like me”, says “become like me.”

He wants them to grow as quickly as possible and become partners.

   This is reinforced by this image in vs. 19 where he compares himself to mother

   in labor—she loves the child but wants him out and own his own. 

 

When a church is holding on to the pure Gospel—

   Christ-formed-in-you maturity is the result.

One reason is because Christ is constantly being glorified and praised

   and men are not. 

Ministers, leaders are seen in proper role as simply teachers and equippers

   for the work all called to do.

 


4.  Gospel churches are transparent, legal churches are guarded.

Throughout this whole passage Paul is so transparent.

   He reminisces about the good times they had together in the early days.

   He expresses grief at the way this legalistic controversy has caused suspicion.

   He tells them what he is thinking—how perplexed he is.

 

This is clearly the pattern Paul set in the early days of the church.

   He lays it all out with them.

Go back to that fascinating opening statement:  Become like me.

 

That does not mean:  Look at me, I’m perfect. 

   It means become like me in my total reliance on Christ.

As you look not just at Galatians but other letters—

   realize that Paul spoke very openly about his struggles, sins, failures.

 

Romans 7, tremendous passage about how so often he doesn’t do

   the good thing he wants to do, and does the thing he hates.

2 Corinthians he speaks of his times of despair.

   Very open about his fears and concerns.

Just as transparent about his joy and confidence in Christ.

 

It had to be that in the early days of the Galatian church—

   with all these new believers coming out of paganism—

   that this rubbed off on them. 

They said Paul, that’s exactly what I’m struggling with.

   That’s such an encouragement to me.

 

That kind of transparency comes from knowing the Gospel.

   It is present in a Gospel church.

Listen to the way Tim Keller puts it:

   “The more you see your own flaws and sins, the more precious, electrifying, and amazing God’s grace appears to you.  But on the other hand, the more aware you are of God’s grace and acceptance in Christ, the more you are able to drop your denials and self-defenses and admit the true dimensions and character of your sin.”

 

But what happens when legalism comes into a church?

It becomes a guarded place. 

   People cannot be transparent.

   Have to old everything very close to the vest.

Because God’s acceptance rests on your performance.

   So to admit failures and struggles in that spiritual environment—

   is to invite questioning that you are really a Christian at all.

So conversations among believers in a legal church become

   more and more guarded, more cliché, if anything—consistently upbeat.

 

There are lots of qualifications I could add at this point.

   About what to share who whom.

   Wisdom of keeping your mouth shut at times and keeping certain things

   between you and God forever.

   And about differences in personalities.

 

But—Let’s just take this point as a general principle.

   In churches where the pure Gospel is loved there will be a level of transparency.

   In churches with a spirit of legalism, there will be guarded speech,

   tends towards cliches.

 

 

Transparency becomes impossible because it is

 


5.  Gospel churches are flawed, legal churches are “perfect.”

 

This whole passage is encouraging in a back handed kind of way.

   In the same way I’m encouraged when I read about Noah getting drunk,

   David falling into sin with Bathsheba, Peter denying Christ.

 

Those stories encourage me because they show people who were true believers

   loved by God, but also sinners deep down to their bones.

That gives me hope that I am also loved by God, even though I’m a sinner

   and that a person can be righteous with the righteousness of Christ

   and still do terrible things. 

 

That’s a dangerous truth. 

   You all know how easily you can turn that around into indifference for sins.

   And if you misuse this truth it can destroy you spiritually.

But it’s a fact. 

   As Christians, aware of our sins, hyper aware because of new life in us—

   we find great comfort in seeing the terrible flaws and sins of true

   believers in the Bible.

There is comfort in the failures of others—whether talking about

   individual Christians or whole churches because we learn through them

   that real believers remain deeply flawed in this life.

 

Here we have it in a whole church.

   A church that was founded by an apostle, founded on the pure Gospel.

   A church that had many sweet early days in which they welcomed,

   grew, were open with one another—all out of amazement at Gospel.

 

But then they went through a season of legalism—where those good things

   dried up—got cold, rigid, guarded.

I find that so encouraging to know that this trouble came to a church

   that the great apostle Paul himself founded and pastored for a time.

 

Because it means that as I see these legalistic evidences in myself,

   my ministry, and in this church—it doesn’t mean all is lost.

The Gospel is for flawed people and flawed churches.

   When we think we are perfect, have none of these tendencies

   that the Gospel ceases to amaze us and give us power.

 

Galatians has a happy ending.

   Acts records Paul’s return visit to these churches—makes no comment.

   Which means that this was a routine visit,

   church had put this unhappy time behind.

Churches go through stages of legalism and grace—

   always a way back by admitting our flaws—and need for Jesus Christ.

 

 

CONC:

 

How do you end a sermon like this?

I could end by saying:  OK Christ Covenant—

   let’s be

   more flexible and accepting of God’s providence,

   more welcoming to the downcast

   more committed to maturing spiritually

   more transparent in conversations with each other.

 

But that’s not the point.

   Those are merely indicators of something deeper—

What did Paul want for this church?  What should we want for ourselves?

   He wanted them to embrace the Gospel again—the good news.

 

The good news is that we are more sinful and wicked than ever dared to admit—

   but we are more loved and accepted than ever dared to hope.

 

In Christ we are righteous sinners, honored failures—

   adopted sons of God, heirs of all his blessings.

 

When we get a hold of that—then the qualities of the Gospel life—

   will be present in us.

 

What better place to do that than at the Table—let’s go there now.